The cozy interior along with the authentic food of Matera's On Park is meant to create a homey Italian atmosphere for Rutherford's Park Avenue. "Everything we make is like Mom’s," Chef and General Manager Erica Russo said. Hoping to bring the culture, food and feel of the Italian city co-owner Mark Forte's family originated from, the business was fittingly named Matera's On Park.

"We didn’t want any of that modern look, we wanted that old Matera feel. Like you’re taking a step toward Italy," Co-Owner Michael Finan said. Matera's prides itself on importing ingredients from Italy and makes all of its dishes locally on-site. Including batches of fresh mozzarella cheese multiple times a day.