A New York City-based eatery known for their cozy candlelit spaces is hoping there is room for one more Italian restaurant in Frank Sinatra’s hometown, as they are opening their first New Jersey location along the main street of the Mile Square City.

Caffe Buon Gusto has been serving hungry New Yorkers for three decades at 151 Montague Street in Brooklyn Heights, later adding a location on Manhattan’s Upper East Side along 77th Street. Crossing the East River worked out so well for them that they’ve officially inked a lease that will take them across the Hudson to 918 Washington Street in Hoboken, the former location of the short-lived Cugini Kitchen.