Ahh, Italiana! Food dominated by sauces, cheeses, herbs and carbs…it’s no wonder the cuisine is so popular. But what is the Best Italian Restaurant on Long Island? Long Islanders voted Grandpa Tony’s the Best Italian Restaurant on Long Island in the 2022 Bethpage Best of Long Island contest!

What makes Grandpa Tony’s the best Italian restaurant on Long Island? Is it the way that its chefs prepare each dish, putting the love and attention of an Italian grandmother into each meal? Or maybe it’s the large portions of all the Italian favorites, including entire pizza, pasta, and chicken menus, so the whole family can mangia bene.