When did you realize Stanley Tucci was hot? Was it when he and Tony Shalhoub built the pasta cake known as a Timpano in Big Night? Or was it when he was Emma Stone’s understanding father in Easy A wearing those tight t-shirts? Maybe it was when he played the supportive husband to Meryl Streep’s Julia Child in Julie & Julia. Or did you figure out you had a weird thing for Caesar Flickerman in The Hunger Games? (No judgment if you did. This is a safe space.)

The thing is: It’s a well-established fact that Tucci is hot. His hotness has been immortalized on novelty t-shirts like the one that reads “I Like My Coffee Like Stanley Tucci . . . Hot” and in BuzzFeed posts like “Stanley Tucci Is Insanely Hot In ‘Easy A’ And We Need To Talk About It.” Vulture once contributed to the Tucci love in the form of the essay “Stanley Tucci’s 12 Most Adorable Movie Roles.”