Lake Como or Lake Garda? It’s as timeless an Italian conundrum as thick crust or thin? Aperol or Campari? The scenery alone draws travelers to these two mythic lakes in northern Italy, both defined by majestic mountains and colorful waterside villages that drip with dreamy dolce vita. So just how do you choose between the two?

“It’s important to decide what kind of holiday vibe and style you want,” says Italy-based Ciao Bambino Travel Advisor Linda Considine.  “If you choose Lake Como, it is going to be a cool, luxurious experience with excellent food and services. If you choose Lake Garda, it is going to be a relaxed, family-friendly, adventure-filled holiday with lots of variety.”